Skip to content

Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll: which is easier and cheaper?

By Updated 9 min read

On this page (8 sections)
  1. The short version
  2. The differences at a glance
  3. Which is easier for onboarding and ongoing payroll management
  4. Which is cheaper for small businesses with 1-50 employees
  5. How the software handles payroll taxes and legal compliance
  6. Which integrates better with existing accounting and HR tools
  7. Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll: which is easier and cheaper?
  8. Questions people still ask

In short: Gusto is generally easier to use than QuickBooks Payroll, while QuickBooks is often cheaper for businesses under 20 employees. For smooth onboarding and less admin friction, choose Gusto if ease matters more, or QuickBooks if cost is key.

Part of our guide on choose between payroll providers

Clear, side-by-side differences in ease and cost help you pick Gusto or QuickBooks Payroll.

At a glance
Ease of useGusto wins
Cost per employeeQuickBooks lower
Employee count limit1-50 typical
Payroll tax filingBoth handled
IntegrationsQuickBooks stronger

The short version

  • Gusto excels at easy onboarding and employee self-service.
  • QuickBooks Payroll integrates well with QuickBooks accounting software.
  • Gusto’s base pricing is higher but includes more features per employee.
  • QuickBooks charges less per employee, better if budget is tight.
  • Both reduce legal risk but differ in tax filings and support options.

The differences at a glance

When comparing Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll, the top factors are ease of use and cost. Gusto is known for its intuitive interface and smoother employee onboarding.

QuickBooks Payroll shines when paired with QuickBooks accounting, offering lower per-employee costs but a steeper learning curve. Both systems handle payroll taxes and filings automatically.

Gusto’s interface is built for simplicity but also transparency, showing payroll status and upcoming deadlines clearly on the dashboard. QuickBooks Payroll’s dashboard, by contrast, prioritizes data depth and accounting links, which can overwhelm new users.

While both offer mobile apps, Gusto’s mobile experience is rated higher for ease of navigation and employee self-service features. QuickBooks Payroll’s app focuses more on accounting and expense tracking, making it less specialized for payroll tasks. If that sounds like your situation, read up on bamboohr vs rippling next.

Another notable difference is how each platform handles multi-state payroll. Gusto supports all 50 states and automatically manages tax registrations for new states you expand into, making it ideal for growing businesses with remote employees. QuickBooks Payroll also supports all states but may require manual registration in some cases, potentially complicating rapid expansion across state lines.

In terms of customer support, Gusto offers phone, email, and chat support during business hours, with some plans including access to certified HR professionals. QuickBooks Payroll provides similar support channels but is known for longer wait times during peak periods. This difference can impact how quickly you resolve payroll issues, especially during critical payroll deadlines.

Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll comparison summary
FeatureGustoQuickBooks Payroll
Ease of UseHigh – clean interface, guided setupModerate – more complex interface
Base Monthly CostHigher starting feeLower starting fee
Cost per EmployeeHigher per employeeLower per employee
Employee Self-ServiceRobust portal and mobile appBasic portal
Accounting IntegrationWorks with many appsBest with QuickBooks accounting
Tax FilingAutomated, with error checksAutomated, integrated with QuickBooks

Which is easier for onboarding and ongoing payroll management

two payroll software dashboards side by side
two payroll software dashboards side by side

Gusto’s user interface is designed for small business owners without HR experience. Its onboarding wizard guides new hires through tax forms, benefits, and direct deposit setup.

Employees can self-onboard and update their information anytime, reducing your administrative overhead. This lowers the chance of errors or missing paperwork.

QuickBooks Payroll requires more manual input and assumes some payroll familiarity. While it does offer employee portals, they’re less intuitive, often leading to more questions or support requests.

If your priority is cutting onboarding time and making payroll management straightforward, Gusto wins clearly on ease.

Beyond the onboarding wizard, Gusto also sends automated reminders to both employees and managers about pending tasks, such as submitting documents or approving time off. This proactive communication helps reduce delays and missed steps in payroll processing.

QuickBooks Payroll requires manual follow-up more often due to less automated nudges, which can slow down payroll preparation especially if the person managing payroll is not dedicated to the role. Small businesses with limited HR personnel may find this a disadvantage.

In addition to onboarding new hires, Gusto also simplifies ongoing payroll management with scheduled payroll runs and auto-pay options that reduce the need for manual inputs every pay period. This can save significant time and reduce errors for businesses processing payroll biweekly or monthly.

QuickBooks Payroll allows for customizable payroll schedules and supports direct deposit for employees, but setting up automatic runs requires manual configuration and monitoring. This may add administrative overhead for small businesses without dedicated payroll staff.

For example, a business with 10 employees running payroll twice a month on Gusto can enable auto-pay and only verify the payroll summary before submission, cutting management time by about 30%. QuickBooks Payroll users might spend 15-20 extra minutes per payroll cycle confirming entries and running reports due to less automation.

What works
  • Intuitive employee onboarding
  • Mobile-friendly portals
  • Automated reminders
What to watch
  • Higher base monthly fee

Which is cheaper for small businesses with 1-50 employees

QuickBooks Payroll usually costs less monthly for businesses with fewer than 20 employees. Its base fee is lower and per-employee charges are cheaper, making it more budget-friendly.

Gusto’s pricing includes more bundled features but comes at a higher monthly cost and per-employee charge, which can add up quickly as you grow.

If your budget is tight and your payroll needs are straightforward, QuickBooks Payroll often delivers better value for small teams.

However, remember that cheaper software sometimes means more time spent managing the system yourself.

For example, QuickBooks Payroll’s Core plan starts at $45 per month plus $4 per employee, while Gusto’s Basic plan starts at $39 plus $6 per employee monthly. If you have 15 employees, QuickBooks would cost about $105 monthly, whereas Gusto would be roughly $129, showing a measurable difference.

However, QuickBooks Payroll sometimes charges extra for state tax filings in certain states, which can increase the total cost unexpectedly. Gusto includes all state filings in its price, providing more predictable budgeting.

While QuickBooks Payroll often offers a lower base price, you need to consider the impact of add-ons. Features like same-day direct deposit or workers' compensation administration may cost extra, increasing the monthly bill beyond the base estimates.

Gusto includes some premium features such as health benefits administration and employee self-onboarding in its standard pricing tiers, contributing to its higher cost but potentially reducing the need for third-party services.

For instance, a 25-employee company opting for same-day direct deposit on QuickBooks Payroll might pay an additional $10 monthly plus $2 per employee, adding $60 to the monthly cost and narrowing the price gap with Gusto. This tradeoff between upfront cost and bundled services should be evaluated carefully.

What works
  • Lower entry cost
  • Good for simple payroll setups
What to watch
  • Less user-friendly interface
  • Fewer bundled HR features
employee using mobile app to complete payroll forms
employee using mobile app to complete payroll forms

Both Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll automate payroll tax filings, including federal, state, and local forms.

Gusto offers error checking and alerts for incomplete or inconsistent data, reducing the risk of audits or penalties.

QuickBooks Payroll integrates this service tightly with its accounting software, which can catch issues if you already use QuickBooks.

For businesses without accounting software, Gusto’s interface and support provide a safer path to compliance.

If reducing legal risk is your goal, Gusto may offer a slight edge in error prevention and guidance.

Gusto’s error checking includes real-time alerts if tax forms are incomplete or if employee information conflicts with IRS records. This can prevent common mistakes that lead to IRS penalties, which average thousands of dollars for small businesses.

QuickBooks Payroll’s compliance checks depend heavily on the accuracy of the linked accounting data. If expenses or payroll entries are incorrect, the tax filing automation may propagate errors, requiring manual corrections after submission.

What works
  • Automatic tax filings
  • Error detection
What to watch
  • Some states have delayed support in QuickBooks

Which integrates better with existing accounting and HR tools

QuickBooks Payroll’s strongest advantage is its smooth integration with QuickBooks accounting software, syncing payroll and bookkeeping automatically.

This saves time reconciling payroll expenses and prevents duplicate data entry errors.

Gusto integrates with many accounting platforms but requires more setup effort and occasional manual checks.

Its ecosystem also supports popular time tracking and benefits platforms better, offering more flexibility if you use diverse tools.

If your business relies on QuickBooks accounting, QuickBooks Payroll wins on integration.

Gusto’s integration supports popular HR platforms such as BambooHR and Deputy, enabling synchronization of employee data and time tracking. This is beneficial for companies using multiple specialized tools rather than an all-in-one solution.

QuickBooks Payroll’s tight coupling with QuickBooks Online means payroll data flows automatically into financial reports, helping business owners keep a consolidated view of finances without manual data exports or imports.

What works
  • Automatic QuickBooks sync
  • Supports multiple HR apps
What to watch
  • Limited integration outside QuickBooks

Gusto vs QuickBooks Payroll: which is easier and cheaper?

calculator and payroll bills on desk
calculator and payroll bills on desk

Choosing between Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll comes down to your priorities and current setup.

If you want the easiest payroll experience with strong onboarding and fewer admin tasks, Gusto is the better choice despite its higher cost.

If cost savings and accounting integration with QuickBooks matter more, especially for smaller teams, QuickBooks Payroll is likely a better fit.

Your selection affects how much time you spend managing payroll and how smoothly your new hires start.

Consider your team size, budget, and existing software before deciding.

Who should pick each payroll service
Business profileRecommended payroll serviceReason
Small teams under 20 with QuickBooks accountingQuickBooks PayrollLower cost and seamless integration
Growing small businesses wanting simple onboardingGustoEasier setup and employee self-service
Companies needing broad HR features with payrollGustoMore built-in HR and benefits support
Budget-conscious with minimal HR needsQuickBooks PayrollCheaper monthly fees
The verdict

Gusto is best for ease and onboarding; QuickBooks Payroll suits budget-conscious QuickBooks users.

Questions people still ask

Can I switch between Gusto and QuickBooks Payroll easily?

Switching payroll providers requires migrating employee data and tax info carefully. It’s doable but takes time and attention to avoid compliance errors. Plan for a transition period with overlapping support.

Does Gusto handle benefits enrollment better than QuickBooks Payroll?

Gusto includes integrated benefits management for health insurance and retirement plans, streamlining enrollment. QuickBooks Payroll supports fewer benefits features, often requiring separate vendors.

Is QuickBooks Payroll suitable without QuickBooks accounting?

QuickBooks Payroll works standalone but loses its integration advantage. Its interface can be less intuitive without QuickBooks, which may increase admin work.

How accurate are the automated tax filings in both systems?

Both services automate filings reliably but depend on accurate input data. Gusto provides more alerts for data issues, potentially offering better error prevention.

Which payroll system supports the most states?

Both cover all US states for payroll tax filings, though QuickBooks Payroll may have delays adding some local jurisdictions compared to Gusto.

I've managed payroll implementations on both systems and value ease over minor cost savings.